U.S. Commission on International Religious Freedom
USCIRF
Institutional Analysis
Institutional transparency is consistently high; analytical methodology has declined measurably across the 1999–2026 scoring window. Counter-evidence engagement is absent or negligible in every scored India chapter.
- D7 (Transparency) scores 6–8 across all 11 scored reports — consistent institutional strength
- D8 (Counter-Evidence) scores 1–3 across the entire series — structural imperviousness to criticism
- Citation infrastructure evolved from zero URLs (1999) to 74 URLs (2024), but analytical framework is static
- 11
- Reports scored
- 3.6
- Avg. score
- 1999–2026
- Years covered
Scored Reports (11)
4.4 Deficient
CID-0017 Policy Report 2025
USCIRF 2025 India Chapter
TIER 3 DATA ACCESSZERO COUNTER EVIDENCE ENGAGEMENT
4.1 Deficient
CID-0020 Policy Report 2019
USCIRF 2019 Annual Report — India Chapter
NO COUNTER EVIDENCE ENGAGEMENTUNDEFINED CHARACTERIZING TERMSTIER 3 DATA ACCESS
4.0 Deficient
CID-0024 Policy Report 2021
USCIRF 2021 Annual Report — India Chapter
UNDEFINED CORE TERMSSCOPE CLAIM MISMATCHTIER 3 DATA ACCESS
3.9 Advocacy-Grade
CID-0014 Policy Report 2026
USCIRF 2026 Annual Report — India Chapter
HIGH SOURCE CONCENTRATIONTIER 3 DATA ACCESSNO COUNTER EVIDENCE ENGAGEMENT
3.8 Advocacy-Grade
CID-0021 Policy Report 2024
India 2024 Country Update
SCOPE CLAIM MISMATCHTIER 3 DATA ACCESSMISSING OPERATIONAL DEFINITIONS
3.6 Advocacy-Grade
CID-0022 Policy Report 2023
USCIRF Annual Report 2023 — India Chapter
TIER 3 DATA ACCESSNO OPERATIONAL DEFINITIONS
3.6 Advocacy-Grade
CID-0015 Policy Report 2008
USCIRF Annual Report 2008 — India Chapter
ZERO CITATIONSNO COUNTER EVIDENCE
3.5 Advocacy-Grade
CID-0011 Policy Report 1999
USCIRF Annual Report 1999
NEAR ZERO EXTERNAL CITATIONSTIER 3 DATA ACCESS
3.1 Advocacy-Grade
CID-0016 Policy Report 2016
USCIRF 2016 Annual Report — India Chapter (Tier 2)
ZERO CITATIONSTIER 3 DATA ACCESS
2.8 Advocacy-Grade
CID-0013 Policy Report 2017
USCIRF Annual Report 2017 — India Chapter
TIER 3 DATA ACCESSSELF REFERENTIAL SOURCING
2.7 Advocacy-Grade cap
CID-0012 Composite Index 2002
USCIRF Annual Report 2002
TIER 3 DATA ACCESSHIGH SOURCE CONCENTRATIONNON COMPENSATORY CAP D3OPAQUE INDEX METHODOLOGY